Monday, October 15, 2018
A new study of female high school soccer players suggests that a neck collar may help protect the brain from head impacts over the course of a competitive soccer season.
“In sports, there’s a heavy focus on single big blows to the head that might lead to what is subjectively described as a ‘concussion,’” said Greg Myer, PhD, director of sports medicine research at Cincinnati Children’s and lead author of the study. “What we really wanted to look at now is the cumulative effect of head impact exposure over an entire season. Evidence indicates that cumulative load of head impacts is potentially more concerning than that one single blow.”
The neck collar device, called a Q-Collar, is designed to press gently on the jugular vein to slow blood outflow, increasing the brain’s blood volume during competitive play. The resulting effect is blood filling the brain vessel (like an airbag) to help the brain fit tighter within the skull cavity, reducing the energy absorbed by the brain during collisions.
The study, published online in the British Journal of Sports Medicine, focused on cumulative sub-concussive impacts to the head that change the white matter structure of the brain. In soccer, that can come from a head ball to a collision with another player to a hard fall.
“White matter is essentially structural pathways that connect all the information/signal processing centers of the brain that support normal function,” said Myer.
Myer and his colleagues studied 46 female high school soccer players. Twenty-four of them wore a Q-Collar. All 46 athletes underwent neuroimaging at up to three points in time over a six-month period. This included the three-month soccer season and three-month post season rest period, with no exposure to head impacts. Head impacts were tracked using accelerometers--a computer chip--placed behind the left ear during practice and games.
Neuroimaging analysis revealed significant white-matter changes from pre- to post-season in those who didn’t wear the collar. No significant changes were found in those who did wear the collar, despite a similar number and magnitude of head impacts.
Imaging conducted three months after the end of the soccer season showed that white matter changes in the non-collar group had either partially resolved or tracked back to normal.
“Certainly, we know the benefits of playing soccer in female athletes far outweigh the risks that we are seeing and that’s an important message we have to take away from this study,” said Myer.
Previous studies involving the Q-Collar looked at male hockey and football players and also showed significant protective effect from repetitive sub-concussive head impacts.
“This could be a paradigm shift in how we study the brain and protect the brain internally from head impact exposure,” said Myer. “We need to continue to do larger studies with various populations and as we move forward with more research we will know more on how effective this approach can be to protect the brain.”
David Smith, MD, co-author of the studies, came up with the idea for the Q-Collar after researching bighorn (head-ramming) sheep and woodpeckers because both animals routinely tolerate high-speed cranium collisions with no adverse impact.
Q30 Innovations designed the neck collar and provided funding for the research.
Myer consults for Q30 Innovations on regulatory matters but has no financial interest in commercialization of the Q-Collar. The Q-Collar has not received regulatory clearance in the United States and is not available here for purchase.
Smith, who has an affiliated position as a visiting scientist at Cincinnati Children’s, does have a financial interest in the results of the current research.