When Breathing Struggles Aren’t Asthma
It’s normal for children to feel winded during exercise. Still, it can be concerning for parents — and frustrating for kids — who have trouble breathing during the activities they love.
“These patients used to be active, and now they can’t keep up. They’re scared,” says William Hardie, MD, a pediatric pulmonologist in Cincinnati Children’s Pulmonary Function Lab. “And their families are worried something is seriously wrong.”
Many of these children have been diagnosed with exercise-induced asthma. But their symptoms don’t get better with rescue inhalers like albuterol. When that happens, Dr. Hardie says it’s time to look for another cause: exercise-induced laryngeal obstruction (EILO), sometimes called vocal cord dysfunction.
EILO can be hard to diagnose. That’s why a team of Cincinnati Children’s experts, including pulmonologists, cardiologists, ear, nose and throat specialists and exercise physiologists, developed a comprehensive protocol to identify patients struggling with this breathing condition.
What EILO Is — and Isn’t
EILO is a temporary blockage of the upper airway that happens during exercise. Dr. Hardie explains that the airway closes using the same reflex the body uses to keep food and liquid out of the lungs. With EILO, that reflex kicks in at the wrong time, making it hard for kids to breathe during strenuous physical activity.
Along with feeling dyspnea, many patients with EILO report gasping for air, choking and feeling like something is stuck in their throat, so it’s hard to take a deep breath in. Another common sign is stridor, a high-pitched, noisy sound that happens during inhalation.
Because these symptoms can look like other breathing problems, EILO is often confused with:
- Asthma
- Dysfunctional breathing
- Exercise-induced bronchospasm
The biggest difference, Dr. Hardie says, is that EILO symptoms peak during a patient’s top physical effort and fade when they stop exercising.
A Unique Diagnostic Protocol for EILO
To diagnose EILO or other causes of exercise limitations, providers need to see a patient’s symptoms as they happen. That’s why the multidisciplinary team at Cincinnati Children’s developed a hybrid exercise test that shows what’s happening in the lungs and heart—all at once.
The hybrid test combines two standardized exercise tests, says Karla Foster, MS, an exercise physiologist and clinical manager of the exercise program for the Pulmonary Function Lab. One is the American Thoracic Society test for exercise-induced bronchospasm that monitors airway responsiveness before and after exercise. The other is a full cardiopulmonary exercise test, which measures how the heart, lungs and muscles work together during exercise.
The 60-to-90-minute test starts with spirometry, a breathing test that measures the flow and volume during a quick forced breathing maneuver. Then patients are also fitted with the following equipment to further understand their current health:
- 12-lead EKG to monitor their heart rhythm
- Blood pressure cuff on the upper arm
- Face mask that measures each breath
- Oxygen probe on their forehead
In some cases, an ENT or pulmonary specialist also guides a scope through the patient’s nose to visualize the larynx during exercise.
During the test, patients typically exercise on the treadmill at a higher intensity for 8-10 minutes while clinicians monitor the heart rhythm, ventilatory responses and patient reported symptoms. After exercise, patients repeat spirometry every five minutes up to 30 minutes to help evaluate airway flow and volume changes from before to after exercise, which aids in the diagnosis or exclusion of exercise-induced bronchospasm.
Cincinnati Children’s is the only hospital in the region that uses this hybrid exercise protocol with additional evaluation of laryngoscopy.
“Continuous laryngoscopy during exercise is the gold standard for seeing whether the vocal cords or supraglottic structures close during physical activity. Without it, the main clue for EILO is stridor,” Foster says. “Laryngoscopy is the most useful when EILO seems severe enough that an ENT might consider surgery.”



